How Much Time Has Passed Between Mamma Mia and Mamma Mia Here We Go Again
11 huge mistakes and plot holes from 'Mamma Mia 2' that make NO SENSE
iii August 2018, 20:twenty | Updated: 11 June 2020, xix:49
And then basically, none of what Donna wrote in her diary was actually true?
Mamma Mia 2 is everything. From the out-of-control memes to the international country of mourning over the fate of Meryl Streep's Donna Sheridan, the net has been obsessed with the second instalment of the ABBA jukebox musical always since it dropped in 2018.
Despite being a potent contender for the best film e'er made (I'm pitiful but the line "Be withal, my beating vagina" ALONE qualifies this movie equally ane of the greatest cinematic creations, don't @ me), in that location is, however, so so so SO many details that don't quite add upward with the plot from the commencement pic. In fact, the timeline is and then completely messed up that almost everything of what Donna states in her infamous diary is contradicted in the kickoff movie.
Afterward an extensive sleuth and many many rewatches, hither are all the mistakes and storyline continuity errors that we've managed to spot across the two films:
i) The timeline makes admittedly no sense.
Here's what we know: Donna graduated from Oxford University in 1979, which means she was in her early twenties when she decided to sack off all her responsibilities and motion to Greece. Assuming all her encounters happened within that yr, it would suggest that Sophie was probably born in 1980.
In the outset motion-picture show, it is explicitly stated several times that Sophie is xx years old - which would point that the film is fix in 2000 (don't allow that 2008 release date fool ya... the phase play really premiered in 1999, in case you were wondering.)
Mamma Mia 2, even so, is fix five years after the first movie - not 10 years, which is the amount of time we waited for the sequel. That means it's 2005 when we arrive back in Kalokairi for the big re-opening of Hotel Bella Donna. But if the twelvemonth is 2005, why is anybody using the latest iPhones when, in real life, they had BARELY been invented yet? WHY? WHY MERYL, WHY?
Wait I but saw Mamma Mia 2, and did anyone else notice that Lily James dead donkey has brown eyes and Meryl Streep has blueish eyes?? Also Sophie is plainly 25 but Donna graduated and got significant in 1979, so the movie should have took place in 2004?? Sophie had an iPhone?? Help???
— Sophie Jackson (@_sophiejackson) July 26, 2018
2) In Donna's diary, she explicitly states that she meets Sam offset. Only in Mamma Mia ii, she meets Harry first.
Most of the continuity errors in the picture stalk from what's written in Donna'a diary aka the MOST Important Office OF THE WHOLE SAGA. In Mamma Mia 2, the showtime guy Donna encounters, and later sleeps with, is Harry, who she meets in Paris before she even makes it to Greece. But according to her diary, she meets Sam beginning and Harry is the one she meets last.
3) Sam didn't row Donna to the island, she met him on the island.
"Sam rowed me over to the little island," Donna writes in her diary, which Sophie later clarifies is in fact Kalokairi. But as we all know, as per the fraudulent timeline of Mamma Mia ii, Donna meets Sam in the center of a pelting storm on the island.
4) Bill didn't "rent" a motorboat, he owned a freakin' boat.
In Mamma Mia 2, Donna only misses the ferry to Kalokairi and ends upward hitching a ride on Nib's gunkhole. Simply as per her diary in the offset movie, she states that Pecker "rented" a gunkhole and she took him to the isle. Honestly, what's the truth?
5) Harry never actually stepped foot on the isle.
In the diary, Donna writes "Harry turned up out of the blue so I said I'd show him the island" only in the second motion-picture show, Harry gets left on the dock as the ferry leaves and turns around and walks away.
There'south actually a reason why the order of the guys change from the first movie, though. Managing director and writer Ol Parker explained that he wanted to make sure each i of Donna's whirlwind romances actually meant something, and that her reasons for sleeping with all iii of them really made sense and resonated with the audition.
"My job was to give her slightly different reasons for each of the men," Parker said. "Young Harry is comedy and a slight pathos and likewise charming. Young Sam is a love story. Immature Bill is to help her feel better from having a broken heart."
I loved Mamma Mia 2 but why didn't Harry turn upwardly out of the blue on August 11th so Donna could testify him the island?
— Clara Rose (@clara_buggy2) July 28, 2018
6) In the diary, Donna says Sam "announces" that he was engaged and leaves to get married - simply it's Donna who finds out instead.
Later Lily James effortlessly hits the states her own flawless rendition of 'Proper name Of The Game', Donna finds Sam'southward journal and promptly realises that he's engaged to another woman. She calls him out on it, storms off and never speaks to him once more.
7) Harry says that Donna'due south guitar was a gift from him only he is still in possession of it at the end of the 2d film.
In the starting time moving-picture show, when Sophie asks Harry why he stole her mum's guitar, he responds: "No, I borrowed it. Wait, DS – Donna Sheridan – and HB – Head Banger. I bought her this, it toll me £ten plus my Johnny Rotten t-shirt."
But at the terminate of the second movie, he's literally standing on the dock with the guitar strapped to his back... wearing his Johnny Rotten t-shirt. Donna doesn't arrive on the island with a guitar either so unless he managed to make information technology back to the isle and requite information technology to her, there's no way she could possibly take it?
viii) And let's non even get started on what the three guys are actually meant to look similar.
WHERE? IS? SAM'Southward? MOUSTACHE? In all fairness, when they decided to add together that throw away gag to the commencement film, they didn't realise they were going to brand a sequel ten years later focusing on the younger versions of those men. Nosotros'll let this one slide...
9) Donna says her mother is dead and Still...
One of the biggest continuity errors betwixt Mamma Mia and Mamma Mia ii is the status of Donna'southward mother. In the first flick, simply later on performing at Sophie'southward Bachelorette party, Donna says "someone up there has got it in for me, I bet information technology's my mother..." implying that her mother is actually dead.
Simply as we all know, Donna'due south mother is not dead. She is alive. And she is Cher.
10) Tanya and Rosie had no thought who the other guys were in the first movie, despite evidently already meeting them back in the day.
Equally Donna recounts the story of the three guys she slept with, Rosie and Tanya act similar they accept no idea that Donna slept with three men in quick succession, or who they actually are. Only in Mamma Mia 2, they know nearly them; they are both introduced to Bill at the tavern and take a take a chance encounter with Sam on the isle likewise. (To be fair, neither Tanya nor Rosie knew who Sam actually *was* when they saw him but withal... THEY KNEW.)
11) If Amanda Seyfried's boobs can tell when it's raining… how come she didn't see that storm happening?
But kidding. (But likewise not really. She really should have forewarned her guests.)
Despite all of those head scratching inconsistencies, the motion picture still remains iconic. The laws of time, infinite and beingness practise not matter on the magical island of Kalokairi - and thank GOD. Otherwise nosotros would not accept been blessed with Cher's presence.
Did you manage to spot any other mistakes or plot holes on your travels? Let united states of america know!
Source: https://www.popbuzz.com/tv-film/features/mamma-mia-2-plot-holes-mistakes/
0 Response to "How Much Time Has Passed Between Mamma Mia and Mamma Mia Here We Go Again"
Post a Comment